More in this section: The Need · Police and Law Enforcement · Healthcare · Training the Chiefs · The Evidence: Table 17
The firefighter’s and paramedic’s hidden cost, and why it can be measured and trained.
Firefighters and paramedics live in other people’s worst moments. They arrive at the fire, the wreck, the overdose, the cardiac arrest, and then they clear the call and drive to the next one, and the next one, all day long, every day. The toll of that is now measured, and it is heavy.
The scale, in today’s numbers
The male firefighter suicide rate is 33.8 per 100,000, nearly twice that of comparable working-age adults, and about one in five (20%) firefighters and paramedics will meet the criteria for PTSD during a career, against a general-population lifetime risk near 7% (U.S. Fire Administration, 2024; National Fallen Firefighters Foundation). In emergency medical services the picture is as stark: more than one in twenty deaths among EMS clinicians is a suicide, more than double the rate in the general public, and Fire and EMS personnel report attempting suicide at many times the civilian rate (Vigil et al., 2019). In 2017, firefighter suicides (103) outnumbered firefighter line-of-duty deaths (93) (Ruderman Family Foundation, 2018).
The cost to the service, not only the responder
In emergency medical services the median cost of replacing a single departing worker is about $71,600 dollars, and 44 percent of those who leave name their own physical or mental health as the reason. Across the country, first-responder PTSD is driving a rising tide of workers’ compensation claims and presumption laws (RAND Corporation). Unmeasured stress does not vanish; it leaves by the exit door and through the claims desk.
The root under the symptom
Behind these numbers is one common thread, and naming it correctly is the whole point. When the U.S. government ran its landmark survey of police stress, more than 2,200 officers across 19 departments, it found that anxiety was correlated with more problems than any other single factor measured: more behavioral, more medical, and more psychological problems than anything else in the study (Hurrell, Pate, and Kliesmet, for NIOSH, 1984). A symptom you can only manage is a very different thing from a root you can learn how to change. Anxiety reduction has a measurable signature in the brain’s own electrical activity (increased and sustained EEG Alpha activity), and that signature can be trained with Neurofeedback. When Alpha EEG activity is trained up with Biocybernaut’s intensive 7-consecutive day Alpha training program, anxiety goes down, reliably, and documented and confirmed in scientific publications in main line journals.
A measured, trainable answer
Why fire and EMS, and not only police
The number underneath all of it: 27
When NIOSH counted, across more than 2,200 officers in 19 different Police departments, which single factor connected to the most problems, Anxiety came first with 27 significant relationships at the .01 level. Depression, the next highest, reached 14. Not one other factor in the entire study even reached 15.
The officers themselves did NOT report feeling anxious. Most rated themselves highest on placidity. The factor most connected to their problems was the one they were least likely to name, and that is precisely why it goes untreated in a firehouse as surely as in a squad room.
This is not an extension I am making because it sounds plausible. It is a conclusion I wrote down in my own research files, in a numbered list of findings: “A very strong economic model suggests great benefits in the application of these advanced Alpha training techniques to police and fire departments.” The next point called for a concerted effort toward high-stress occupations generally. The economic model suggests that the cost of this training is much less than the costs of the consequences of not applying this training.
The physiology problem does not check your uniform. A firefighter arriving at a scene and a police officer arriving at the same scene are running the same machinery under the same load, and the brain signal underneath is the same signal.
For over fifty years my work has asked one question: can a person learn to change the electrical activity of their own brain, and does it help? The answer, documented and published, is yes. Strongly, YES!
- In the journal Science in 1978, Dr. Joe Kamiya and I showed that anxiety is inversely related to the brain’s Alpha activity, and that teaching high anxiety people to raise their Alpha lowers both momentary State Anxiety and the deeper, Trait Anxiety that behaves like a fixed part of the personality.
- Peniston and Kulkosky reported an 80 percent recovery rate in chronic alcoholics with this kind of training, showed it changed the brain’s own beta-endorphin chemistry, and then reported success in treating post-traumatic stress in Vietnam veterans.
- In 1985 I trained two twelve-man teams of U.S. Army Special Forces, the Green Berets. In direct proportion to the Alpha they gained, their depression, paranoia, and rigidity of thinking fell and their intuition, self-regard, and self-actualizing values rose, several at high statistical significance. Two-thirds of these elite soldiers chose to do extra Alpha training sessions on their own free time.
- Biocybernaut’s own federal grant research files make the leap explicitly, concluding that a very strong economic model suggests great benefits in applying these training techniques to police and fire departments alike. The mechanism is the same in a fire station as in a squad room: it works on the nervous system, not the uniform.
- With San Jose, California’s Police Chief McNamara’s enthusiastic support, this research became the subject of a formal grant application to the National Institute of Justice, the research arm of the U.S. Department of Justice, and proposed to run a Biocybernaut Alpha training program as a controlled study of 200 San Jose Police officers. The Alpha training does not ask a suffering person to be stronger. It measures the root cause and trains it away. None of this is a promise of cure or a piece of medical advice; it is a case for measuring the thing that is actually driving the harm, and training it down by training the brain’s Alpha activity up.
If you carry this condition, or you command those who do
If you lead a fire service, an EMS agency, or a first-responder union, the numbers above are your people, and the cost above is already on your books. And if you are the person in that role yourself, quietly carrying more than you can say to anyone, this page is for you most of all.
Please talk with us. My assistants will hear you out properly, with no pressure and no performance review, and they will tell you honestly what they think, including if they think this Alpha brain wave training is not the right fit. When a conversation goes further, it can sometimes come as far as me directly. I will not pretend that is automatic, because it is not, but people do ask, and it is a fair thing to ask for.
You can reach us at biocybernaut.com/contact-us, or call 855-798-3814. That line reaches Alexis directly, including after hours, and can forward to Kate O’Connor.
And if you are in immediate danger right now, please reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (call or text 988) or your local emergency number first. That help exists this minute; we do not replace it.
References
U.S. Fire Administration, Mental Health & Well-Being Workgroup Report, 2024; National Fallen Firefighters Foundation.
Vigil, N.H. et al. Death by Suicide: The EMS Profession Compared to the General Public, 2019.
Ruderman Family Foundation, 2018 (2017 data).
Hurrell, J.J., Pate, A., & Kliesmet, R. Stress Among Police Officers. NIOSH Technical Report 84-108, 1984.
Miletich, J.J. Police, Firefighter, and Paramedic Stress: An Annotated Bibliography. Greenwood Press, 1990.
Hardt, J.V. & Kamiya, J. Science, 201, 79-81, 1978. Peniston & Kulkosky, 1989/1993.